Undead teams kills a Star Player. Do they get a Zombie?

[lunchmoney]

Relevant pages, I think, are 92 Apothecary stating you cant use it on a Star but after a match the Star will have any CAS result reversed, even death;
and the Masters of Undeath bit about getting a zombie.

It could be said the Star is not dead so no zombie can be had.
It could be said the Star is dead, so you get a zombie.
It could be said the Star is dead, so you get a zombie, but after the match he is resurrected and you lose the zombie (I favour this one).

Thoughts everyone else?

Capture.jpg

Capture2.jpg

[Tulkas]

The star player can be saved by his own team of apothecary, so it cannot be changed to a zombie.

My interpretation only involves me and my multiple personnalities and they aren't even all okay with that.

[Lyracian]

Star is dead, so you get a zombie, but after the match he is resurrected and you KEEP the zombie.

The Star rule just keeps the star in the game. Master of Death gives you a Zombie.

If you want the fluff maybe they got a True Res spell and a new body or traded you a fresh body for that of the star they want.

[howlinggriffon]

Is this one that needs to be emailed to GW so they can add it to a FAQ? (Although in the case I imagine it's more an IAQ - infrequently asked question )