Page 2 of 2
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2017 11:09 pm
by daloonieshaman
Q: If a player from your team fails to catch a ball from a kick-off, and the ball
bounces over the line of scrimmage is it a touchback?
A: Yes, any event that causes the ball to go out of bounds or over the line of
scrimmage during a kick-off results in a touchback
well that is what a FAQ is for to straighten out a poorly written rule
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Thu Jul 06, 2017 11:11 pm
by daloonieshaman
Twelfman wrote:Question: If the ball is going to land between two pieces on opposing teams that have DC, who decides if they're going to use it first or not? Person 1 might want to use it but person 2 might not. Or vice versa.
if both choose to use it then neither can
so one the same team:
player one tries to use DC and fails you cannot decide to use player 2 to use DC because they would cancel each other out
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Fri Jul 07, 2017 12:05 am
by Darkson
He said "opposing" players.
P.14 of the CRP (sorry, no idea in BB2016) - "If both coaches want to use a skill to affect the same Action or move, then the coach whose turn is taking place must use his skill first."
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Fri Jul 07, 2017 1:09 am
by GalakStarscraper
daloonieshaman wrote:well that is what a FAQ is for to straighten out a poorly written rule
Easy to throw stones from the sidelines ... isn't it.
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Fri Jul 07, 2017 2:25 am
by daloonieshaman
GalakStarscraper wrote:daloonieshaman wrote:well that is what a FAQ is for to straighten out a poorly written rule
Easy to throw stones from the sidelines ... isn't it.
I can only afford the top row of the nose bleed section
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Fri Jul 07, 2017 6:39 am
by dode74
daloonieshaman wrote:well that is what a FAQ is for to straighten out a poorly written rule
You cannot, with limited wordspace, make clarifications for every rule interaction within the wording of each rule. FAQs can be a preemptive catchall for those clarifications as well as answering any subsequent actual questions.
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Fri Jul 07, 2017 12:16 pm
by Twelfman
Darkson wrote:He said "opposing" players.
P.14 of the CRP (sorry, no idea in BB2016) - "If both coaches want to use a skill to affect the same Action or move, then the coach whose turn is taking place must use his skill first."
Boom, cheers.
Derailing a bit, but that reminds me of another scenario (which I'm sure has been answered dozens of times)
Player A has Dodge, Player B has Diving Tackle. Which is correct:
Player A rolls a 1 for the Dodge, player B doesn't therefore use Diving Tackle. Player A rerolls dodge and succeeds on a 2+. Can B use DT still?
Or
Play A rolls a 1 for the dodge, then rerolls it and gets a 2. Player B then decides whether to use DT.
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Fri Jul 07, 2017 12:41 pm
by Loki
Player B decides whether to use DT after 1st roll, if not used on 1st roll player again has choice after the 2nd dice roll.
So if 1st roll is a 1, the DT can choose not to use it; after 2nd roll they may choose to not use it either as roll is low e.g. 1 or high e.g. 6 as in either case DT and therefore there player being prone does not make a difference to the result. If DT was used to create fail on first roll player must stay prone for re-roll whether opponent rolls a 1 or 6.
ps CRB said "...Diving Tackle may be used on a re-rolled dodge if not declared for use on the first Dodge roll..."
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Fri Jul 07, 2017 12:46 pm
by lunchmoney
+1 to what Loki said
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Fri Jul 07, 2017 1:02 pm
by Twelfman
Awesome, thanks. Now, about Hypnotic Gaze from prone...
(joking)
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Sun Jul 09, 2017 3:23 pm
by GalakStarscraper
dode74 wrote:daloonieshaman wrote:well that is what a FAQ is for to straighten out a poorly written rule
You cannot, with limited wordspace, make clarifications for every rule interaction within the wording of each rule. FAQs can be a preemptive catchall for those clarifications as well as answering any subsequent actual questions.
There are days I wish this forum had a Like or Agree button.
Re: Diving Catch - 2 players with the skill
Posted: Sun Jul 16, 2017 9:40 am
by landrover
GalakStarscraper wrote:dode74 wrote:daloonieshaman wrote:well that is what a FAQ is for to straighten out a poorly written rule
You cannot, with limited wordspace, make clarifications for every rule interaction within the wording of each rule. FAQs can be a preemptive catchall for those clarifications as well as answering any subsequent actual questions.
There are days I wish this forum had a Like or Agree button.
+1